01.06.2005 00:45

The Einstein centenary


This year is the centenary of four scientific papers by Albert Einstein.

It seems that the least known paper of the four is 'On the Motion of Small Particles Suspended in a Stationary Liquid According to the Molecular Kinetic Theory of Heat'. Einstein extended the work of Ludwig Boltzmann, calculated the average trajectory of a microscopic particle buffeted by random collisions with molecules in a fluid or in a gas, and gave a estimate for the size of the molecules.

The paper presented a mathematical formula for Brownian motion, the random displacement of particles suspended in a fluid. The motion could be explained by molecules with random energy moving in random directions, randomly striking the particles. Einstein used the framework of James Clerk Maxwell's and Ludwig Boltzmann's kinetic theory of gases to estimate the size of molecules. One of the assumptions, unproven and controversial in 1905, of the kinetic theory is that gases are composed of a large collection of hard, spherical objects in constant motion. Introduction to the Kinetic-Molecular Theory of Gases. This is an ideal gas, provided that the collisions are perfectly elastic.

Robert Brown was the observer who gave his name to the phenomenon. Brown's investigations of fertilization in flowering plants observed with his microscope lead hem to dissect pollen sacs and suspend the pollen in water. The suspended grains were filled with particles in constant motion. Was this the motion of life? Brown argued 'no', since he observed the same motion in pollen grains preserved for eleven months in alcohol. His further observations of minerals in suspension supported his conclusion that the motion belonged to the particles themselves, and not to any activity of life.

Brown was a member of the Linnean Society, and the week Charles Darwin received Alfred Wallace's paper on the 'survival of the fittest', Brown died. His death on June 10, 1858, caused the postponement of the Society's regular meeting until July 1. At the July 1 meeting, the Darwin-Wallace paper was read to members.

Until Einstein's explanation, many scientists doubted whether atoms and molecules physically existed. Atoms and molecules were a very useful assumption, but other scientists rejected the atomic theory of matter. In 1905, the first law of thermodynamics could be understood in terms of the motion of Newtonian atoms. But mechanical behavior could not explain the second law, because the second law is irreversible: a melted ice cube does not refreeze. Einstein's estimate of the size of molecules provided critical support for the atomic theory, and his analysis used statistical methods to describe the behavior of the enormous number of atoms or molecules in a gas. The kinetic theory of gases and the atomic theory of matter (rather than Wilhelm Ostwald's energeticist view), began to decisively win out. Ostwald later said that reading Einstein's paper converted him to the atomic explanation. (Einstein's father unsuccessfully wrote to Ostwald in 1901 seeking a position for his son, when he couldn't find work.)

Tragically, Boltzmann, after decades of work on the kinetic theory and the application of statistics to describe the behavior of atoms and molecules, committed suicide in 1906.