Winds of
Change prints a Maryland Free Soil Party ticket from the 1848
election. Many years ago, someone told me that back then, political
parties printed and distributed the tickets, with only their
candidates' names on them, no one else. Here's the image, from the
Smithsonian's article on
Paper
Ballots:

Ballot, Free Soil ticket
Maryland Free Soil party ticket, 1848
The Smithsonian has other interesting images at the link.
Before the Civil War 'only Kentucky and Virginia were electing by
voice vote. Kentucky, which had had the paper ballot from 1792 to
1799, was the last state to abandon voice voting.'
Ballot from the Encyclopedia Americana. Interesting that they
abandoned paper ballots after seven years and had voice voting for
another seven decades.
'Party-tickets' were used after the Civil War, and the first State
to adopt the 'Australian' ballot, printed by the government, with
all candidates listed,
was
Massachusetts, in 1888. It was the Progressive Movement which
eliminated ballots printed and distributed by parties, which also
involved the government is ballot access questions, leading to our
time's petition signature campaigns and litigation by Ralph Nader,
the Libertarian Party and other minor parties. Richard Winger is
usually cited as the authority on ballot access. His web site is
Ballot Access
News.